Winners of the Contest to Rename CaRP Evolution
Posted by Antone Roundy under CaRP , Web Content Pipeline10 Comments
Thank you to everyone who participated in the contest to rename CaRP Evolution. I got a lot of great suggestions. Last night, I picked my five favorites, added an idea of my own to the list, and painstakingly eliminated them one by one to arrive at the winner.
The final names that I was considering weren’t exactly the names that had been suggested, but each of the top suggestions included a word that either captured part of the essence of what CaRP does, or would have been useful in communicating that quickly to people not yet familiar with CaRP, or in some cases even with RSS. I took those words and created a bunch of combinations using other words I thought I might use in the name. That gave me a list of 28 possibilities.
I asked my wife for her opinion, but other than reinforcing my decision to eliminate all the combinations containing one of the terms, she didn’t have much to say. Oh well, it’s my contest — I guess I have to decide!
So, on to the winners.
First, I’ve decided that Julie (who’s last name I’m not sure of, but you know who you are!) who suggested holding the contest should get the same prize as the first place winner — her choice of any three Gecko Tribe products.
Next, the third place winner (who gets his choice of any one Gecko Tribe product) was the first person to submit a suggestion, Shawn Collins. His suggestion was Site Feeder.
The second place winner (who gets any two Gecko Tribe products) is Frank Thomas, who suggested RSS Commander.
This contest has been a bit controversial. I’ve received emails and blog comments from people who think renaming CaRP is a terrible idea, and others who think it’s a great idea that’s long overdue. I imagine the new name will be loved by some and hated by others as much as the very idea of renaming CaRP.
What makes this all even more fun is that the winning suggestion came from an unknown person! I’m not going to tell you what their suggestion was (you’ll see why in a minute), but I will tell you that the new name for CaRP (when I get the next revision completed) will be Web Content Pipeline. The sales copy will run along the lines of “connect a content pipeline to your website”, “pipe in content from blogs, news sites, YouTube, podcasts, Amazon.com affiliate feeds and more”, etc.
Here’s how we’re going to (hopefully!) find out who submitted the winning suggestion: If you submitted a suggestion similar to “Web Content Pipeline”, contact me through my help desk using the web form (don’t send en email — the web form will make it more likely that I’ll be able to verify against the IP address of the person who submitted the suggestion), and let me know (as nearly as you can remember):
- what your suggestion was
- when you submitted it
- what three Gecko Tribe products you’d like to receive
- where to send them
- and your name, so that I can announce who the winner is!
If no one claims the first prize before the end of the day on February 10, I’ll bump up everyone who was in the second through fourth positions.
Everyone who won prizes, either email me if you have my email address or use the help desk form linked to above to let me know which prizes you’d like and where to email them. You can find a list of products on the Gecko Tribe homepage.
Thanks again to everyone who participated! We’ll soon know whether this was a good idea or not!
Related Posts
- Twidget/WP Lists Latest Twitter Posts in Your WordPress Sidebar
- 2 Crazy Deals – Promoting My Competition!
- CaRP In The Wild: AffiliateSummit.com
- Contest to Rename CaRP Evolution Till January 31
- “The Swiss Army Knife of RSS Scripts” – 2 New Plugins for CaRP Evolution
- Affiliate Afterburner: Special Deal for First 250 Buyers
February 3rd, 2009 at 1:50 pm
it will always be CaRP to me. Otherwise, how would I remember it? :)
February 3rd, 2009 at 2:12 pm
Hey you are receiving emails, but no comment responses here?!?
Considering you already a have a number of pages with great PR and a following already for Geck CaRP, why change?
Either which way, I still love the product! Now let’s see if we can get some feedback on this post
February 3rd, 2009 at 2:56 pm
Sounds like a great name to me. I’ve always found it odd that the name of this product is also the name of a fish, a bottom-feeder at that. Always seemed like a bad association. So this is definitely an improvement.
February 3rd, 2009 at 3:33 pm
Carp s great, new name is quite forgetable. No offense to the winner – it is a great descriptive label for selling Carp, but as a brand name it just makes my shoulders shrug.
It is not too late to change your mind and go with the BRAND NAME you have created and that reeled me in.
February 3rd, 2009 at 4:46 pm
I agree with Sam – you want something people will remember. I’ve remembered and gone back to CaRP for years. I would not change it at all.
February 3rd, 2009 at 6:54 pm
Personally, I like the name CaRP but it’s probably because I’ve spent the last few years using it.
I agree with Sam’s comment that Web Content Pipeline is somewhat forgettable though.
Why not call it the CaRP Web Content Pipeline? That way, you still keep the brand that many of us have grown to know and you can still use the Web Content Pipeline analogy in all the sale material?
Just a thought.
February 3rd, 2009 at 8:23 pm
Yeah, the name is quite descriptive, but by the time I had scrolled to the bottom of the page I had forgotten it! Branding is going to suffer.
In addition to your products, I use Yahoo Pipes, and you might consider focusing on the “Pipeline” part of the name. Also, remember what “WC” means in Britain. What will Brits think of “WC Pipeline” as a name? ;-)
February 4th, 2009 at 3:53 am
Sky beat me to it…
Seems we are moving from CaRP (which my dyslexia always caused me to see as CRaP)…
To WC (UK toilet) P (pee)..
So that maintains the toilet-based (should I say rest-room-based) connotations for me!…
(Not to mention pipes!)
But then that’s just how my sad brain works ;)
…Just sorry I missed a chance to submit my ideas:
“Super Hot Internet Timesaver”
or
“Putting Online Output Properly On Our Sites” (though maybe that’s a bit long of a name?)
lol
February 4th, 2009 at 11:11 pm
Antone You would be crazy to drop a brand name so well established. (If you do then please give it to me. I will heaps of stuff with such a well known internet term)
I think your customer above has the best suggestion “Carp Content Pipeline”, the Web bit doesnt add anything.
If you really need a reason to keep carp then its: CARP (Content And Rss Pipeline)
February 4th, 2009 at 11:54 pm
Hey Antone,
I happen to think the name is really great!! But, as you can see by my screen name I like names that are kind of way out there! Not that your products names are ‘way out there’.
You are right. You will get those that aren’t happy that you’ve changed it (as noted in some of the comments above). But, they will calm down, soon enough, and you will have a very descriptive name for your great product. I really do like the new name, a lot!
Too bad I didn’t come up with it myself. But, lucky for me you are a very generous guy!
Thanks a lot for the free gifts – the same prize as the mysterious first place winner, is really cool and totally unexpected! I’ll be in touch once I decide which ones I’d like.
I’m really glad that my modest suggestion for you to hold a contest was so helpful to you!!
Congrats on the new name!
~Julie~